Have you ever read a book then a year or so later they come out with the movie, but they movie has many different aspects then the book did? There are many to choose from but the one that came to my mind was My Sister’s Keeper by Jodi Picoult. Usually the books are always better because the details that the author discusses. If I had to choose on which was better I would definitely pick the book, even though they both made me cry!
My Sister’s Keeper is a very powerful story. The oldest daughter Kate gets diagnosed with cancer, leukemia to be exact. Kate’s younger sister, Anna was a conceived child that was brought into the world to act as a savior child for her sister. As Anna grew older she was always willing to give up whatever she needed to save her sisters life. As the years came and go, the day came where Anna had to give her sister one of her kidneys, this meant that both the daughters would undergo major surgery with no promises of surviving. Anna’s parents were always making the decision of surgery on their own without even consulting with Anna first. So when the kidney surgery came up, Anna petitioned for a medical emancipation which would allow her to male her own decisions.
One of the differences that caught my eye was that the book was way more realistic then the movie was. The book gives more detail on how the characters are feeling and what they are going through, compared to the movie where it seemed like they were rushing the whole plot and didn’t give much of anything. The biggest difference to me is the ending of both the book and the movie, they are completely different. In the book, Anna wins her case, but before she gets the chance to tell whether or not she was going to donate her kidney stone, Anna gets involved in an accident that leaves her brain dead. Anna’s lawyer grants the kidney stone to Kate and Anna was sent up to heaven instead of her sister. The ending in the movie is completely different, which makes many people very upset. Right before the case is decided, Jesse who is Kate’s older brother, reveals to the family that Kate doesn’t want to undergo surgery. The mother sides with Kate. Kate ends up dying instead of Anna. After the death of Kate, Anna’s lawyer claims that she has won the case and that she has medical emancipation from her parents.
Even though both the book and the movie made me cry, I believe that the book is a lot better because of the details and descriptions that are enforced in the story. Many books and movies have this problem. Most of the time the books are way better because it leaves your imagination open to how you want to see the story played out. The movies leave people in disappointment or even shock because they leave very important parts out, and sometimes what you have pictured when you are reading the story, is completely different from what the movie has to offer and that can be disappointing.http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HP4NxUFgFrs Even though it is a lot easier to just sit down and watch a movie rather then read a book, almost always it is well worth your time to read the book because you could miss out on something important.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HP4NxUFgFrs
Monday, September 26, 2011
Thursday, September 22, 2011
movie/book
Have you ever read a book then a year or so later they come out with the movie, but they movie has many different aspects then the book did? There are many to choose from but the one that came to my mind was “My Sister’s Keeper” by Jodi Picoult. Usually the books are always better because the details that the author discusses. If I had to choose on which was better I would definitely pick the book, even though they both made me cry!
My Sisters Keeper is a very powerful story. The oldest daughter Kate gets diagnosed with cancer, leukemia to be exact. Kate’s younger sister, Anna was a conceived child that was brought into the world to act as a savior child for her sister. As Anna grew older she was always willing to give up whatever she needed to save her sisters life. As the years came and go, the day came where Anna had to give her sister one of her kidneys, this meant that both the daughters would undergo major surgery with no promises of surviving. Anna’s parents were always making the decision of surgery on their own without even consulting with Anna first. So when the kidney surgery came up, Anna petitioned for a medical emancipation which would allow her to male her own decisions.
One of the differences that caught my eye was that the book was way more realistic then the movie was. The book gives more detail on how the characters are feeling and what they are going through, compared to the movie where it seemed like they were rushing the whole plot and didn’t give much of anything. The biggest difference to me is the ending of both the book and the movie, they are completely different. In the book, Anna wins her case, but before she gets the chance to tell whether or not she was going to donate her kidney stone, Anna gets involved in an accident that leaves her brain dead. Anna’s lawyer grants the kidney stone to Kate and Anna was sent up to heaven instead of her sister. The ending in the movie is completely different, which makes many people very upset. Right before the case is decided, Jesse who is Kate’s older brother, reveals to the family that Kate doesn’t want to undergo surgery. The mother sides with Kate. Kate ends up dying instead of Anna. After the death of Kate, Anna’s lawyer claims that she has won the case and that she has medical emancipation from her parents.
Even though both the book and the movie made me cry, I believe that the book is a lot better because of the details and descriptions that the enforced in the story. Many book and movies have this problem. Most of the time the books are way better and the movies leave people in disappointment or even shock because they leave very important parts out. Even though it is a lot easier to just sit down and watch a movie rather then read a book, almost always it is well worth your time to read the book because you could miss out on something important.
My Sisters Keeper is a very powerful story. The oldest daughter Kate gets diagnosed with cancer, leukemia to be exact. Kate’s younger sister, Anna was a conceived child that was brought into the world to act as a savior child for her sister. As Anna grew older she was always willing to give up whatever she needed to save her sisters life. As the years came and go, the day came where Anna had to give her sister one of her kidneys, this meant that both the daughters would undergo major surgery with no promises of surviving. Anna’s parents were always making the decision of surgery on their own without even consulting with Anna first. So when the kidney surgery came up, Anna petitioned for a medical emancipation which would allow her to male her own decisions.
One of the differences that caught my eye was that the book was way more realistic then the movie was. The book gives more detail on how the characters are feeling and what they are going through, compared to the movie where it seemed like they were rushing the whole plot and didn’t give much of anything. The biggest difference to me is the ending of both the book and the movie, they are completely different. In the book, Anna wins her case, but before she gets the chance to tell whether or not she was going to donate her kidney stone, Anna gets involved in an accident that leaves her brain dead. Anna’s lawyer grants the kidney stone to Kate and Anna was sent up to heaven instead of her sister. The ending in the movie is completely different, which makes many people very upset. Right before the case is decided, Jesse who is Kate’s older brother, reveals to the family that Kate doesn’t want to undergo surgery. The mother sides with Kate. Kate ends up dying instead of Anna. After the death of Kate, Anna’s lawyer claims that she has won the case and that she has medical emancipation from her parents.
Even though both the book and the movie made me cry, I believe that the book is a lot better because of the details and descriptions that the enforced in the story. Many book and movies have this problem. Most of the time the books are way better and the movies leave people in disappointment or even shock because they leave very important parts out. Even though it is a lot easier to just sit down and watch a movie rather then read a book, almost always it is well worth your time to read the book because you could miss out on something important.
Wednesday, September 21, 2011
Thursday, September 1, 2011
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)